Pressure Treated vs Cedar: Which is Better for Your Deck?

When it comes to choosing materials for your outdoor decking or fencing projects, two popular options that often come into consideration are pressure-treated wood and cedar. Both have their own sets of advantages and disadvantages, which we will explore below to help you make an informed decision.

Benefits of Cedar Decking

Cedar decking is celebrated for its natural beauty and durability. The Western Red Cedar, in particular, is a favorite due to its structural integrity and lightweight, making it easy to handle during construction.

• Natural Pest Resistance: Cedar contains natural oils that repel pests and resist moisture, extending the lifespan of the decking by preventing rot.
• Aesthetic Appeal: Cedar's rich hue and distinctive grain make it visually appealing and adaptable to different home styles.
• Environmental Considerations: Cedar is eco-friendly as it requires no harsh chemicals during its production process.

Comparison with Pressure-Treated Decking

Pressure-treated wood is often chosen for its affordability and long-lasting nature, but it comes with its own set of issues:

• Inconsistent Quality: The performance of pressure-treated wood can vary based on its quality, leading to potential drawbacks like warping.
• Aesthetic Decline: Over time, pressure-treated wood may lose its aesthetic appeal, making it less favorable for visible areas.

In contrast, cedar is superior in maintaining consistent quality and aesthetic appeal over time.

Key Factors for Choosing Decking Material

• Budget: While cedar is more expensive than pressure-treated wood, it offers a mid-range option compared to high-end composites.
• Maintenance: Cedar requires regular upkeep but can maintain its beauty and durability for many years with proper care.
• Aesthetics: For a natural wood appearance, cedar is often preferred.
• Durability: Cedar's natural resistance to rot and pests ensures longevity.

General Comparison: Cedar vs. Pressure Treated Lumber

Both cedar and pressure-treated wood are popular for outdoor use due to their resistance to insects and rot. Below is a detailed comparison:

Pros and Cons

Pressure Treated Lumber

• Pros: Durable, cost-effective, longer lasting in ground contact
• Cons: Prone to aesthetic decline, chemical leaching concerns, tricky to paint

Cedar Lumber

• Pros: Naturally resistant to decay, lightweight, aesthetically pleasing
• Cons: More expensive, softer and prone to scratches, not ideal for constant ground contact

Maintenance Tips

Both cedar and pressure-treated wood require maintenance to stay in good condition. Here are some tips:

• Cedar: While not necessary, staining cedar can enhance its longevity and maintain its appearance.
• Pressure Treated: Requires preservative coating on cut ends and regular staining to prevent fading and cracks.

FAQs

• Can you paint pressure-treated wood? Yes, but it often leads to peeling. Ensure it is completely dry before painting.
• Does cedar wood crack easily? Yes, especially at the ends. Pre-drilling is recommended to prevent splitting.
• Does cedar wood need to be sealed? It’s optional. Unsealed cedar will develop a rustic gray over time, while sealing will prolong its life.

Cedar vs Pressure Treated Wood, Which is Best For You?