The 9 Best Frozen Pizzas of 2024: Top Picks and Reviews

Frozen pizza is a beloved staple for many, often evoking warm memories of childhood or college days. It stands out as a distinct category in the culinary world, appreciated for its convenience and unique characteristics. Here's a closer look at the best frozen pizzas, balancing nostalgia, quality, and taste.

Frozen pizza has a distinct place in our hearts, often evoking memories of simpler times. Whether it’s a quick meal after a long day or a nostalgic treat, its convenience is unmatched.

Nostalgia and Convenience

"Pizza! (serving suggestion)" by jeffreyw is licensed under CC BY 2.0. To view a copy of this license, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0/.

Frozen pizza is often seen as a nostalgic food, representing childhood meals or college days. Despite differing opinions on its quality, it remains a go-to option for quick and easy meals.

Quality Matters

Not all frozen pizzas are created equal. To identify the best, we conducted a taste test of 26 widely available frozen cheese and pepperoni pizzas. Here are the key factors we considered:

Crust texture (soft vs. thin)
Quality and flavor of the tomato sauce
Variety and quality of cheeses used

Taste Testing Overview

"Pizza: Grilled chicken, artichoke hearts, and arugula" by ecospc is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0. To view a copy of this license, visit https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/2.0/.

A blind taste test ensured an unbiased evaluation, with each pizza scored out of 10 based on taste. Below are detailed reviews of some notable options:

Pizza Reviews

Brand	Score (out of 10)	Review
DiGiorno Rising Crust Four Cheese Pizza	4/10	Crust: Too thick and doughy, resulting in a soggy texture. Sauce: Bland and flavorless. Cheese: Processed, with a tendency to pull off the slice. Price: Almost double compared to others, deemed not worth the cost.
Jack’s Original Thin Cheese Pizza	5/10	Overall taste: Average Crust: Surprisingly crispy
Tombstone Five Cheese Pizza	6/10	Flavor and appearance: Appreciated Crust: Enjoyable but not remarkable Issue: Loose cheese during unwrapping
Red Baron Classic Crust Four Cheese Pizza	7/10	Crust: Flavorful with a yeasty taste Sauce: Savory without overly sweet notes Cheese: Lacked proper melting, giving a chalky texture
Screamin' Sicilian Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza	9/10	Crust: Crispy with a pleasing texture, fluffy yet crunchy Sauce: Salty, with herbs like oregano and basil enhancing flavor Cheese: Most akin to fresh mozzarella compared to other brands Note on Availability: Only found in small size locally, could be pricier for full size

Recommendation

Frozen pizzas serve as an excellent option for quick meals when time is short. Based on our taste tests, the Screamin' Sicilian Bessie's Revenge Cheese Pizza stands out as the best choice for its nearly authentic pizza experience.

Ranking 14 Frozen Pizzas | Ranked with Babish

If you're wondering how to properly recycle your pizza boxes after enjoying a slice, check out how to dispose of or recycle pizza boxes.

In conclusion, keeping a few high-quality frozen pizzas in the freezer can be a lifesaver for unplanned dinners. Choose wisely, and enjoy an effortless, satisfying meal.

For more pizza inspiration and to stay connected, follow us on our social media profiles: Pinterest, Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook.